Equal Pay Day
Equal Pay Day is an annual event that highlights the ongoing wage gap between men and women. It is observed in the United States and other countries around the world on different dates each year, depending on how long it takes women to earn the same amount of money that men earned in the previous year.
The idea of Equal Pay Day was first introduced in 1996 by the National Committee on Pay Equity, a non-profit organization that works to eliminate wage discrimination. The date of Equal Pay Day is calculated based on the wage gap between men and women, which is typically expressed as a percentage. In the United States, for example, women earned 82 cents for every dollar earned by men in 2021, which means that Equal Pay Day was observed on March 24, 2021 (because it took women an additional 82 days to earn the same amount of money that men earned by December 31, 2020).
Equal Pay Day is an opportunity to raise awareness about the persistence of wage discrimination and to advocate for policies and practices that promote pay equity. Some of the actions that individuals and organizations can take on Equal Pay Day include:
- Sharing information about the wage gap and the impact of wage discrimination on women and their families.
- Encouraging employers to conduct pay equity analyses to identify and address any disparities in pay.
- Calling on elected officials to support legislation that promotes pay equity, such as the Paycheck Fairness Act in the United States.
- Highlighting the contributions of women to the workforce and the economy, and advocating for greater recognition and compensation for their work.
While Equal Pay Day is an important reminder of the ongoing struggle for pay equity, it is important to recognize that the wage gap is just one manifestation of broader inequalities that affect women and other marginalized groups. Achieving true equity and justice will require sustained efforts to address these broader issues, including systemic racism, discrimination, and unequal access to opportunities and resources.
The Equal Pay Act, signed into law in 1963, is a federal law that prohibits wage discrimination based on sex. The law requires that men and women be paid equally for doing the same job, with equal skill, effort, and responsibility, and under similar working conditions. While the law has been in place for almost 60 years, wage disparities between men and women still exist. In California, there are additional laws that supplement the Equal Pay Act to further protect employees from wage discrimination.
The Equal Pay Act
The Equal Pay Act (EPA) was signed into law by President John F. Kennedy in 1963 as an amendment to the Fair Labor Standards Act. The law prohibits employers from paying employees of one sex less than employees of the opposite sex for equal work, with the exception of situations where the pay differential is based on seniority, merit, quantity or quality of production, or any other factor other than sex. The EPA applies to all employers subject to the Fair Labor Standards Act, regardless of the size of the business or the number of employees.
The EPA also prohibits retaliation against employees who complain about wage discrimination or participate in an investigation or lawsuit related to wage discrimination. The law provides for both back pay and liquidated damages (an additional equal amount of back pay) for employees who successfully prove wage discrimination.
California’s Fair Pay Act
California has had an equal pay law since 1949, but the state’s Fair Pay Act (FPA), signed into law in 2015, strengthened and expanded the state’s protections against wage discrimination. The FPA requires employers to pay employees of different genders who perform “substantially similar work” the same wage. California law permits certain pay differences based on seniority, merit, quantity or quality of production, or a qualifying bona fide factor other than sex, race, or ethnicity, such as education, training, or experience. The employer must satisfy the statutory requirements, apply the factors reasonably, and show that they account for the entire pay difference. Prior salary cannot justify an unlawful pay disparity.
In addition to prohibiting wage discrimination, the FPA requires that employers provide employees with a pay scale for their position upon request. The law also prohibits employers from retaliating against employees who ask for or discuss wage information.
California’s Gender Recognition Act
In 2018, California passed the Gender Recognition Act (GRA), which allows individuals to identify as nonbinary and have their gender recognized on official documents such as driver’s licenses and birth certificates. The GRA also prohibits discrimination based on gender identity, including in the workplace.
The Equal Pay Act was a crucial first step in addressing wage discrimination based on sex, but more work is needed to achieve true pay equity. In California, the Fair Pay Act and the Gender Recognition Act provide additional protections for employees against wage discrimination and discrimination based on gender identity. Employers must be vigilant in ensuring that they are paying employees of all genders equally for equal work, and employees should be aware of their rights under these laws and speak up if they believe they are being unfairly compensated.
The Paycheck Fairness Act
The Paycheck Fairness Act is a proposed piece of legislation in the United States aimed at addressing the gender wage gap. The bill seeks to strengthen the Equal Pay Act of 1963, which prohibited pay discrimination on the basis of sex, by providing additional tools for enforcement and increasing transparency around pay.
If passed, the Paycheck Fairness Act would:
- Prohibit employers from retaliating against employees who discuss their pay with colleagues.
- Require employers to prove that pay disparities between men and women are not based on sex, but rather on factors such as education, training, or experience.
- Allow employees to sue for compensatory and punitive damages in cases of pay discrimination.
- Require the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) to collect pay data from employers and share it with the Department of Labor.
- Provide funding for research and education programs aimed at closing the gender pay gap.
How to File an Equal Pay Claim in California
If you believe you are being paid less unlawfully, you can take steps to document the difference and explore your options. California’s Civil Rights Department (CRD), formerly called the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH), accepts equal pay complaints. Depending on your claims, you may also pursue a civil lawsuit or file with the California Labor Commissioner.
Step 1: Gather Your Pay Records
Collect records showing your compensation over time, including:
- Pay stubs, W-2 forms, offer letters, and employment agreements.
- Records of bonuses, commissions, stock awards, and benefits.
- Communications about starting pay, raises, promotions, or compensation decisions.
- Job descriptions, performance reviews, and records of your responsibilities.
Keep original files when possible and only collect documents you may lawfully access. You do not need a complete set of records before seeking advice or beginning the complaint process.
Step 2: Identify Employees Performing Comparable Work
A “comparator” is an employee whose work and compensation can be compared with yours. For a California Equal Pay Act claim, document whether higher-paid employees of another sex, race, or ethnicity perform substantially similar work when skill, effort, and responsibility are considered together, under similar working conditions.
Focus on actual duties rather than job titles. Useful information includes:
- The tasks each employee performs and the responsibility each carries.
- The training, education, or skills the positions require.
- The working conditions and relevant periods of employment.
- Compensation information coworkers voluntarily share.
- Any explanation the employer gave for the pay difference.
A pay difference alone does not automatically prove a violation. An employer may establish a legally permitted justification, such as a seniority or merit system, if the statutory requirements are met. An attorney can help evaluate the comparison and the employer’s explanation.
Step 3: Choose Between an Agency Complaint and a Civil Suit
CRD complaint: Begin by submitting an intake form through the CRD complaint process. Provide the employer’s information, relevant dates, a description of the pay disparity, supporting documents, and witness information. CRD reviews the allegations and determines whether to accept a formal complaint for investigation. It may investigate, pursue resolution, or take legal action in appropriate cases.
California Equal Pay Act lawsuit: A claim under Labor Code section 1197.5 may be brought directly in court without first completing an agency complaint process. An attorney can assess the evidence, prepare the complaint, and pursue additional records through litigation.
Related employment discrimination lawsuit: If you also pursue pay discrimination under California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), you generally must first file with CRD and obtain a right-to-sue notice. You may request an immediate notice instead of a CRD investigation. That choice means CRD will not investigate the complaint, so discuss it with an attorney before proceeding.
Labor Commissioner complaint: You may also file a California Equal Pay Act complaint with the Labor Commissioner’s Office using its online process or Equal Pay Act Complaint form (EPA 1). Review the Labor Commissioner’s filing guidance for instructions.
Step 4: Check the Statute-of-Limitations Timeline
The deadline depends on the law and filing route. Under current law, the general timelines are:
- California Equal Pay Act wage claim: Generally, file within three years after the last date the cause of action occurs. An unlawful compensation decision, becoming subject to it, or receiving compensation affected by it can trigger the claim. Each affected payment can constitute a new violation.
- California FEHA pay discrimination complaint: Generally, submit your CRD intake form within three years of the last discriminatory act.
- FEHA lawsuit after a CRD right-to-sue notice: Generally, file within one year of the date of the notice. This deadline does not replace the separate California Equal Pay Act deadline.
- Federal Equal Pay Act claim: Generally, file within two years of the discriminatory pay, or three years for a willful violation. You do not need an EEOC charge before bringing this lawsuit, and filing an EEOC charge does not extend the lawsuit deadline.
- Related federal Title VII pay discrimination claim: An EEOC charge is generally required before a lawsuit. In California, the charge deadline is generally 300 days, subject to applicable coverage and exceptions.
The filing deadline and the period of recoverable compensation are different. California’s current Equal Pay Act permits relief for a violation period of up to six years, subject to the law’s application to the claim. This does not give you six years to file.
These timelines are general rules. Exceptions, older claims, public-sector procedures, and retaliation claims may require a different analysis. Do not assume that reporting the issue internally or pursuing one filing route preserves every other claim.
Step 5: Keep Records and Seek Advice Promptly
Save copies of submissions, confirmation notices, agency correspondence, and any right-to-sue notice. Respond to requests for information and document any threats, discipline, reduced hours, or other possible retaliation after discussing pay or asserting your rights.
You do not need to prove your entire case before asking for help. An employment attorney can review the available evidence, identify missing records, and help you choose a filing strategy that protects applicable deadlines. Overall, the Paycheck Fairness Act aims to provide stronger legal protections for women in the workforce and promote greater equality in pay.
Is Your Pay Equal?
If you feel you’ve been denied equal pay by a current or past employer, you may have a legal case to pursue a claim. Reach out to our experienced, passionate equal pay and employee rights lawyers at Matern Law Group, PC for a free consultation today. We are committed to obtaining justice for you. We pride ourselves on delivering exceptional legal services to all our clients. Get in touch by filling out the form below, or calling us directly at: 855-913-1134.
Equal pay resources: